Inside Psychotherapy | (917) 310 – 0512 | 119 W. 57th Street NY, NY 10019 | 26 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11242

The Mental Toll: Understanding Decision Fatigue and Its Impact on Everyday Choices

By Madison Weber, MHC-LP.

Should I take the subway or the bus? Do I have time to stop for coffee on my way to work? Should I go to the gym? Can I afford to go on this trip? 

From the moment we wake up until we go to bed, decisions are an integral part of our daily routine. 

From choosing what to wear in the morning to making crucial career choices, our brains constantly engage in a complex web of decision-making processes, and the sheer volume of decisions we face can be overwhelming. 

Have you ever found yourself feeling mentally drained and indecisive after a day filled with numerous choices? 

This phenomenon is known as decision fatigue, a psychological state that can affect the quality of our decision-making and overall well-being. 

What is decision fatigue?

Decision fatigue is a psychological concept that describes the deteriorating quality of decisions and the mental, emotional and physical depletion of a person after a long session of decision making. 

Decision-making is a complex cognitive process that engages various regions of the brain. Every choice we make, whether it’s selecting what to wear, what to eat, or which route to take, requires mental effort and resources. 

As we navigate through countless choices, our brains work tirelessly to weigh options, consider consequences, and make informed decisions. 

The more decisions we confront, the more our cognitive resources become depleted, leading to a decline in decision-making quality. 

This cognitive cost is at the core of decision fatigue.

Think of decision fatigue as the mental wear and tear that accumulates throughout the day.

For anxious individuals, decision fatigue can be exacerbated, as anxiety tends to heighten sensitivity to choices, making even minor decisions feel monumental. This can lead to a paralyzing fear of making the wrong choice, perpetuating a cycle of stress and indecision.

Overwhelming Options and Paralysis

People often describe feeling “paralyzed” when they feel incapable of making a decision, which is a phenomenon aptly named analysis paralysis

We are inundated with an abundance of choices and being constantly influenced by products, especially living in a capitalist society in one of the largest cities in the U.S.  

While having options is generally considered a positive, an excess of choices can overwhelm you as a decision-maker. 

The phenomenon of analysis paralysis occurs when individuals are faced with too many options, causing them to feel stressed and unable to make decisions.

Whether it’s choosing a product from a vast array of options or deciding on a restaurant from a lengthy menu, the sheer volume of choices can contribute significantly to decision fatigue. 

The fear of making the wrong decision, coupled with the effort required to sift through numerous options, can lead to decision-making paralysis.

How do I mitigate decision fatigue? 

Prioritize and Simplify:
  • Start by identifying the most critical decisions that require your attention. 
  • Focus on what truly matters and let go of unnecessary choices. 
  • You may be wondering, but what do I do with the decisions that are not a priority? 

Delegate: 

  • Recognize that you don’t have to carry the burden of every decision alone. Delegate tasks or seek input from others, whether it’s at work, in personal relationships, or even when choosing where to eat. 
  • Sharing the decision-making load can alleviate stress.

Establish Routines:

  • Simplify your daily routine to reduce the number of decisions you need to make, freeing up mental space for more important matters.
  • Establishing routines can provide a sense of structure and stability.
  • Whether it’s meal planning, getting into a morning ritual, or laying out an outfit the night before, creating automatic parts of your day or week will allow you to conserve mental energy for more significant choices. 

Break Tasks into Smaller Steps:

  • For larger decisions, break them into smaller, more manageable steps. 
  • This not only makes the process less overwhelming but also allows you to focus on one aspect at a time, easing the burden of decision making.
  • Tip: Write down the large task at hand and break it down into smaller parts. As you complete each step, check it off of your list until you’ve tackled the whole task! Writing things down can help free up your mental space. 

Take Breaks:

  • Incorporate short breaks into your day to recharge. 
  • Whether it’s taking a short walk, stretching, practicing mindfulness or listening to music, stepping away from decision-heavy tasks can help refresh your mind.

Limit Choices:

  • Offering yourself fewer options can be liberating.
  • Whether it’s choosing from a menu or deciding what to wear, narrowing down choices to a manageable number can alleviate the stress associated with decision making. 
  • Set boundaries to avoid the overwhelming feeling of unlimited possibilities.

Practice Mindfulness:

  • Incorporate mindfulness techniques into your daily routine to stay present and centered. 
  • Techniques such as deep breathing or meditation can help calm anxiety and improve focus, making decision making more manageable.

While these tips can be useful for some to implement, others may be looking for a tailored approach to addressing their decision fatigue about specific experiences in their lives. 

In that case, I recommend reaching out to a therapist for support as you develop these skills and apply them in your life. 

Decision fatigue is a universal challenge, and for those with anxiety, it can be particularly daunting. 

Remember, it’s okay to seek support and adopt a mindset that values simplicity and self-compassion. 

By understanding the concept and implementing strategies to combat it, you can reclaim control over your decision-making process and improve your overall well-being. 

Share Post

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *